Around The Pulse
REVIEW: Squadron Supreme Vol. 2 #1

Writer: Howard Chaykin

Artist: Marco Turini

Colours: Guru eFx

Publisher: Marvel Comics

So, yet another alternate Marvel Universe makes an appearance this week, although in fairness this one has been around in one form or another since the 1970s. Following J. Michael Straczynski’s 2006 re-launch and the events of the Ultimate Power crossover with the heroes from Marvel’s Ultimates universe, Squadron returns to the page with a new creative team of Howard Chaykin and Marco Turini. Gruenwald, JMS, Gary Frank… there are some really big names previously associated with this book. So how does this new-look team shape up?

Series artist Turini may be a newcomer to Marvel Comics, but he is joined by acclaimed creator Howard Chaykin, who has a reputation for producing quality books (check out his writer / artist work on American Flagg & Power and Glory for some excellent reads) with a critical examination of the impact of politics and media on society – themes nicely in keeping with the premise behind this new universe.

So, given the near cataclysmic events of Ultimate Power, and the cast changes that occurred as a result (most important of which being the Ultimates’ Nick Fury remaining behind in the Supreme world), where does Chaykin take things from here?

Well, rather than taking the more conventional route of concentrating on the whereabouts of the established heroes, Chaykin instead spends the majority of this first issue exploring new characters and elements that are no doubt going to play major roles in this six-part storyline, while moving the action five years into the future. The aim appears to be to bring together various disparate but interlinked elements and characters, and this serves the story well in terms of seamlessly introducing new scenarios into the already established universe.

As a starting point for new readers, this is actually quite successful, albeit at this point trading character development for tension, plot, and intrigue. There are hints to new super-powered beings, astronauts returning from space, and the possibility of a spreading virus, all while the established actors Fury, Burbank and Arcanna Jones try to uncover a conspiracy recently brought to their attention.

Given Chaykin’s interest in the impact of media, it is not at all surprising that he utilises news broadcasts as one narrator alongside the more traditional directional techniques used throughout. This may not be particularly innovative, but it serves the story well to provide not only a brief recap of previous events, but more importantly conveying the emotional landscape of the current world order.

Surprisingly, there are one or two clichés which seemed a little out of place within the quality of the writing generally on offer, such as opening the issue with an attempted rape and a rather too striking similarity with the Fantastic Four, but perhaps this will turn out to be intentional.

This series marks the ongoing Marvel debut of artist Turini, who I believe was unearthed during Marvel’s recent artist talent search Chesterquest, overseen by Marvel editor C.B. Cebulski. Turini provides a nice balance between the super-powered elements of the story and those steeped more in the general un-powered population at large which fits the apparent tone of this series nicely, and generally he has a good handle on form and movement. Sequentially, the storytelling works fine too, so as an early piece of Marvel work it is something he should be proud of. However, there is nothing particularly exciting or dynamic about the visuals – again, this may fit well within the general tone of the book, but it didn’t leap off the page at me. But Turini has the basics right, he has plenty of time to develop his own style, and also hopefully will have the opportunity to learn from an industry great like Chaykin.

Coming into this with very little knowledge of the history of the Supreme universe, I have to admit that as an overall package, while there are some interesting elements here, I was rather underwhelmed by the issue, and there is nothing in these 22 pages to convince me that this is a ‘new’ universe I need to explore. That said, for die hard fans or those new readers still intrigued by the concept, then this is for the most part a well crafted issue with some obvious potential – and I wouldn’t bet against Chaykin making something more interesting out of this yet.

Rating: 6

Last 5 posts by Mark Stoddard

One comment for “REVIEW: Squadron Supreme Vol. 2 #1”

  1. [...] free to check out Mark Stoddard’s review for a slightly less positive [...]

    Posted by Comics Nexus | CAPSULE REVIEWS Marvel Week 27 2008 | July 22, 2008, 5:05 pm

Post a comment

Check This Out!
Authors
Categories
Archives
Add Us On Twitter!

You can now follow Comics Nexus on Twitter to get our latest updates!
Polls

The newest Comics Nexus interface:

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...




Comics Nexus - The Comics Nexus is written by a group of lifelong diehard comic book fans, who have an appreciation for the artistry, writing and consistency of well-known and obscure titles. Longtime comics fans will find kindred spirits in the Nexus, and new fans will better understand the history and context of today’s hottest heroes by reading the Nexus’s deep selection of commentary, reviews and features.

Part of the Inside Pulse network copyright 2004-2009. Inside Pulse is proudly powered by Wordpress. Inside Pulse also uses and recommends the following technologies - Fyrebug for Flash Games, Blubrry Power Press for Streaming Audio Podcasts and streaming video.